Local SEO
When to fire your SEO company (and when to keep them)
You have paid an SEO company for months and cannot tell if anything changed. Here is the test we use on our own work, and the two cases where firing them is the wrong move.
Published · 11 min read · Answered by Daniel Girmay and Darin Pirkey
Fire your SEO company when they cannot put a dollar amount on their work, or show what they track, why, where you started and where you are now. If they never asked about your revenue goal at signup, it is already past time. If the phone is ringing and jobs are closing, keep them.
We took this exact question on our weekly Q&A, video above. The contractor who asked had been paying for months and could not say whether anything had improved. When that happens, the problem is often not the money. It is that nobody agreed up front what the money was supposed to do.
How do you tell if SEO is working?
SEO is working if the agency can show you where your numbers started, where they are now, and how much revenue the change produced. That is the whole test. Everything else in a report is supporting detail.
The reason this matters is that reports are easy to shape. As we said on the call: “Reports are just reports, right? You can make reports look a certain way to make yourself look good as an SEO agent.” Most contractors do not live inside Search Console or Analytics, and an agency that wants to look good can pick the date range, the metric and the comparison that flatters the work. More impressions. More clicks. A ranking that moved from eleven to seven. All of that can be true while your call volume sits flat.
So the questions to ask are simple. What are we tracking? Why are we tracking it? Where did we start? Where are we now? And then the one that ends most of these conversations: can you put a dollar amount on it?
Think of it the way you would think about any other place you put money. On the call we put it this way: you would not put money in the stock market and never check whether it was growing. You would look at the number. An SEO contract is no different. If the agency cannot attribute revenue, then at the bare minimum they should attribute leads. If they cannot do either, you are paying for activity, not outcomes.
What are the signs it is time to fire your SEO agency?
The clearest sign is that nobody can connect the work to a dollar. Here are the others, in the order we would weigh them.
They never asked about your revenue goal. You hired them because you had a plan for the business. More jobs in a certain service line. A second crew. A new town. A good agency asks what that plan is before they quote, then maps their work to it. If that conversation never happened, the relationship was never pointed at anything. As we said on the call: “If they didn’t ask that from you in the first place, I would argue it’s already past time.”
The report is all rankings and impressions, no leads. Rankings are a means. Calls and booked jobs are the end. A report that stops at the means is measuring the agency, not your business.
You are not getting the calls you think you deserve. You know your market. If competitors with similar reviews and similar work are visibly busier, and the agency has no explanation beyond “SEO takes time”, that is a problem. We wrote about what usually sits behind that in why a competitor is getting more calls than you.
You are not expanding. If one of your goals was new service areas and nothing has moved on that front, the work is not aligned with the goal. Expansion is something we do. The method is not something we publish, but the outcome is not hard to check. Either you are getting calls from the new area or you are not.
They promise a position. Google’s own Business Profile help page says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking, and that local results are mainly based on relevance, distance and prominence. No one outside Google controls those factors, so an agency that guarantees number one is promising something it cannot deliver. That tells you how the rest of their claims are built.
They cannot explain what they do each month. You should not need to understand the mechanics. You should be able to get a plain answer. If the answer is vague every time, assume the work is too.
One or two of these on their own might be a communication problem. The first one, the missing dollar amount, is not. That one is the decision.
My SEO agency is not getting results. Should I fire them right away?
Not on the spot. First get clear on what they are doing and what it has produced, because the fact that you are asking usually means you do not know either.
That sounds blunt, but it is the useful part. On the call we made the point that the question itself comes from a lack of clarity, on what the agency is doing and on what it is generating. Answer those two things before you decide. Pull the last three reports. Write down what was tracked. Write down your call volume and job count for the same months. Compare.
Then separate two failure modes, because they get different treatment.
The first is an agency that is not doing the work. Few deliverables, no explanation, reports that repeat. That is a firing.
The second is an agency that is doing the work and the work is producing the wrong thing. More clicks, more profile views, better positions, and no more revenue. That is also a firing, but it is worth understanding why before you move, because the next agency will inherit the same problem if you do not fix the target. The target is revenue. On the call: “It’s not just about clicks and calls. It’s about revenue.”
One more thing before you pull the trigger. Know your numbers even if you decide to stay. It is just as important to track when things are working as when they are not, because that is how you find out what caused a change. If you raised your ad spend last quarter, or changed a variable on your profile, or switched your call tracking, you need the data to tell which lever moved the phone. Without it, every decision after this one is a guess.
How fast can SEO work?
Honest answer: it depends on where you start, and a good agency will tell you which number should move first and roughly when. Local SEO for a contractor is measured in months, not weeks. That is true. It is also the line every bad agency hides behind.
The way to keep that line honest is to insist on a baseline and on leading indicators. Before anything moves to revenue, you should see movement in things like profile actions, call volume from Maps, and the share of calls coming from the jobs you actually want. If the agency can show those climbing, the revenue claim is at least plausible. If they cannot show anything moving and keep asking for patience, patience is not the issue.
Here is what the pattern looks like when it is working, from our own clients. A cost per lead that starts around $60 to $70 at the beginning of an engagement, then falls over the following months with no increase in what the client pays and no change in the number of profiles, because rankings improve and more of the calls come from the buying range. Cost per lead goes down. More importantly, cost per job goes down. That is the kind of trend you should be able to see on a single page. If your agency cannot produce that page, ask why.
Some of what moves those numbers is not mysterious. Your primary category, complete profile information, your reviews and your replies to them are all on the list Google gives for improving local ranking. We cover the one that matters most in why your GBP primary category is the whole ballgame.
When should you keep your SEO company?
Keep them when the phone is ringing and you are closing the jobs you want, even if the reporting is thin. That was our opinion on the call, and it is a contrarian one for an SEO company to hold. If you are getting a strong volume of calls every month and you do not care about dashboards, fine. It is working. Do your thing.
Keep them too in a case we get asked about a lot: “They got me results, but now I don’t think they are doing anything.” Be careful here. If the results are still there, the work that produced them may still be working. On the call we put it as “if it’s not broke, don’t try to fix it.” Rankings that hold, calls that hold and a cost per job that stays down can be the result of maintenance you do not see. Firing in the middle of a run that is still paying, because the reports got boring, is the most expensive mistake on this page.
What you should do in that case is ask for the attribution anyway. Not because you are leaving, but because knowing the number when things are good is what lets you spot the month things turn.
The relationships that last are not vendor relationships. As we said on the call: “The longest relationships are essentially just partnerships.” The agency knows what you are trying to build, the work is pointed at it, and the numbers get reviewed by both sides. We turn down way more people than we accept because we want the owner invested in their own business too. An owner who only wants to be number one, and does not care whether number three would bring more calls, is not a fit for us. We said that plainly on the call: “What if number three got you more calls? Would you care?” We shoot for number one. We care about revenue.
What should a good SEO company show you every month?
A good SEO company shows you attribution, a baseline, the current numbers and the plan, in that order. In practice that means:
- The objective, in your words. What you told them you wanted when you signed.
- What they are tracking and why each metric connects to that objective.
- Where you started and where you are now, same metrics, same method.
- Leads attributed to the work, and revenue where you can give them job data.
- Cost per lead and cost per job, trending over time.
- What they did this month and what they plan to do next month.
Rankings, clicks and views belong in there as evidence. They do not belong at the top. If you want a feel for what moves those supporting numbers, whether Google reviews help ranking is a good place to start, because it is the lever most owners can pull themselves.
If your agency says attribution is impossible for a contractor, it is not. Call tracking, form tracking, asking the customer how they found you and matching it to the job in your CRM are all ordinary. They take setup and discipline, not magic. An agency that will not do that setup is choosing not to be measured.
Is a cheaper SEO company the better deal?
The price of the contract is the wrong number to anchor on. The right number is cost per job, which is what the contract costs divided by the jobs it produces. A cheap retainer that produces nothing is expensive. A larger one that drops your cost per job every quarter is cheap.
We wrote a full breakdown in SEO agency cost for contractors, including what is usually inside the price and what is usually missing. If you are weighing an agency against doing it yourself with software, read AI SEO tools vs an SEO agency before you decide either way.
What are common SEO mistakes contractors make with an agency?
The most common mistake is signing without stating the revenue goal, which leaves the agency free to define success as whatever their report shows. The rest follow from it.
- Judging the work by a ranking instead of by calls and jobs.
- Not tracking calls at all, so nobody can attribute anything.
- Changing several things at once, new ads, new profile category, new website, and then crediting or blaming the agency for the result.
- Firing during a run that is still producing because the monthly report feels repetitive.
- Hiring the next agency with the same vague target as the last one.
And the honest trade-off: switching agencies is not free. Expect a reset period while the new company learns your market, your profile history and your numbers. That cost is worth paying when the current agency cannot connect work to revenue. It is not worth paying to go from one unmeasured relationship to another. Fix the target first.
How do you fire your SEO company without losing your rankings?
You keep your rankings by keeping the assets. Rankings live on your domain, your Google Business Profile and your review history, not inside the agency. Before you send the notice:
- Confirm you are the owner of your domain and hosting, with the login.
- Confirm your Google Business Profile is owned by an account you control, and the agency is a manager at most.
- Confirm you have owner access to Search Console and Analytics.
- Export every report they have sent you, and the baseline if they ever set one.
- Ask which links, listings and call tracking numbers the agency controls, and whether they stay live after you leave.
- Ask in writing for a list of what they did and where it lives, so the next team can pick it up.
If the agency owns any of those on your behalf, get ownership transferred before the contract ends. That is the single thing that turns a clean break into a lost year.
Once the break is done, the work still has to be done. If you want a team that will set the baseline and report against revenue, that is what our local SEO service for contractors and our map pack ranking work are built around.
What to do this week
Send your SEO company one email with two questions. One, what dollar amount, or at minimum how many leads, has your work generated since we started, and how did you measure it. Two, what are you tracking, why, where did we start and where are we now. Give them a week. A good agency answers quickly and is glad you asked. A bad one sends you a ranking report. Either way, you will have your answer.