Local SEO
How to get higher value jobs from Google
The phone rings, Google sent the call, and it is another small repair you did not want. That is a positioning problem, not a Google problem, and it is fixable.
Published · 10 min read · Answered by Daniel Girmay and Darin Pirkey
You get higher value jobs from Google by making your most profitable service the center of your website, your Business Profile and your reviews, and by giving small repair topics less attention. Google ranks local results on relevance, distance and prominence. If your site talks more about couple-hundred-dollar repairs than replacements, repairs are what it sends.
We took this exact question on our weekly Q&A, video above. The contractor said Google was sending plenty of calls, but mostly for the small stuff. Here is the full reasoning, including the part where we tell you not to hate the small jobs.
Why is Google only sending me small jobs?
Google sends you small jobs because small jobs are what you told it you do. Not on purpose, but that is the result.
Google’s own ranking guidance says local results are mainly based on relevance, distance and prominence, and that relevance is how well your Business Profile matches what someone is searching for. Google says providing complete and detailed business info helps it understand your business and match it to relevant searches (Google’s local ranking tips). That matching does not stop at your profile. Your website, your service pages, your reviews and your photos all tell Google what kind of business you are.
Most contractors build out the repair side first because it is easier. A repair page is quick to write. The keyword is easier to rank for because, as we said on the call, your competitors probably do not want those jobs either, so they never bothered to go after them. You win the keyword, the calls start, and you feel like Google is working. Then you look at the ticket sizes.
On the call, one of us put it plainly: “you’ve optimized yourself from a search in the direction of a small job.”
That is the mechanism. The good news is that it means Google already trusts you. You are not starting from zero. As we said on our weekly Q&A, “Google is trusting you in your space, which is great. And all you’ve got to do is redirect it to the right type of customers that you want to serve.”
What is the difference between small-job content and bottom of funnel content?
Bottom of funnel content is written for the person who is ready to hire, and that is the content that wins higher value jobs.
Think about where the person is in their buying journey. Someone searching how to patch a leaking shingle wants a cheap fix or a DIY answer. Someone searching roof replacement cost or roof replacement near me has already decided they are spending real money. They are at the bottom of the funnel. They are the customer you want.
What we typically recommend is giving the DIY stuff less attention so you can focus on the bigger stuff. That does not mean you can never write a repair page. It means the weight of your site, the volume of what you publish and the direction of your reviews should all lean toward the service that pays.
Here is the test. Open your website and count the pages. How many are about the service you want more of? How many are about the service you are tired of? Now do the same for your last 20 reviews and your Business Profile photos. If the small stuff outnumbers the big stuff, you have your answer.
How do I position my business for the jobs I want?
You position for higher value jobs by making the profitable service your bread and butter everywhere Google looks, instead of listing every service you can technically do.
Pick the service and make it unmistakable
On the call, the question we kept coming back to was this: are you making it very clear that the big job is your bread and butter, or are you just being a generalist? A generalist site reads like a menu. Repairs, replacements, inspections, gutters, maintenance, all given equal weight. Google reads that and has no idea what you are best at, so it matches you wherever the competition is thinnest. That is usually the small stuff.
Your most profitable service should be in your homepage headline, your primary service page, your Business Profile description and your primary category. If you are not sure your category is right, read why your GBP primary category is the whole ballgame. The category is the single strongest signal of what you are, and a lot of contractors have it set to something generic.
Audit your keywords, not just your pages
SEO stands for search engine optimization. You are optimizing how you present on the search. Most people throw a bunch of keywords on the site and hope something sticks. Each keyword has a different level of difficulty, and each one takes a different level of input to rank. If you spread yourself across ten services, you rank fastest for the easiest one, and the easiest one is almost never the most profitable one.
Sit down with your keyword list and ask three questions. Which of these are the jobs I actually want? Which are my competitors already targeting? Which ones am I ranking for only because nobody else cared? Then cut the third group out of your content plan. Do not delete the pages. Just stop feeding them.
Point your reviews at the big jobs
Reviews are part of your positioning. If every review says “fixed my leak fast, fair price,” Google and the customer both learn that you are the leak guy. Ask for reviews after your bigger jobs and ask the customer to mention what the job was. A review that says “replaced our entire roof in two days” does more for your positioning than ten reviews about a patch. For the ranking side of this, see whether Google reviews help ranking and what actually moves it.
Match your photos and posts to the same message
Photos of full replacements, full system installs and full remodels. Not photos of a single shingle. Your Business Profile should look like the business you want to be hired as. Google’s guidance says photos and videos show customers what you offer, so use that space to show the expensive work.
If this sounds like a lot to track at once, it is the core of what a proper local SEO engagement for contractors is built around: one direction, one bread and butter, every signal pointed the same way.
Should I stop taking small jobs altogether?
No. Small jobs are often the front door to big ones, and treating them as garbage costs you money.
This was the part of the call we wanted to make sure did not get lost. As we said on our weekly Q&A, “Don’t assume that all smaller jobs are only smaller jobs.” It depends on your niche, but take roofing. A homeowner calls about a few shingles. You go out, do good work, and you are now the roofer they know. When that roof needs replacing, you get the call. If the leak has caused structural damage, the repair becomes a replacement right there.
We have a client who does really well with smaller jobs first that turn into larger jobs, because they do so well on the actual site visit that the customer trusts them with the bigger ticket. They do not mind the small jobs. They actually want them, because the small job is the easiest sales call for the big job they will ever get.
There is also the insurance angle, which we noted on the call. In certain Florida counties, once the damaged area passes a set number of squares, the insurer treats it as a replacement rather than a repair. The customer called about damage. The adjuster turned it into a replacement. The roofer who answered the small call got the big job.
This is lifetime value. The first ticket is not the measure of the customer. The total over the years is. Bigger jobs have a longer buying cycle, and most people are not looking to replace their roof when they only have a little damage. They want the damage fixed. Being the one who fixed it is how you are in the room when the replacement decision happens.
So the honest answer is two things at once. Lean your positioning toward the big jobs, and keep answering the small calls with your best people, because a chunk of them are big jobs in disguise.
Will I still get small jobs after I reposition?
Yes, and that is fine. Trust flows downhill.
As one of us said on the call, if you rank for roof replacements and roof installs, you will still get roof repair calls. The customer finds you for the big thing, trusts you because of it, and asks on the phone whether you also do repairs. The difference is who is calling. A customer who found you as the replacement company sees you as the serious option. A customer who found you as the cheapest patch sees you as a patch.
Same job type, very different lead. One is price shopping. The other already decided you are the expert and is just checking you can fit them in.
What is the mistake we see most?
The mistake we see most is service stuffing, and we see it time and time again with multi-service companies.
The owner is proud of everything the company can do, so every service goes on the homepage, every service gets a page, every service gets a mention in the Business Profile description. The site becomes a list. Google cannot tell what you are best at, so it ranks you wherever the competition is thinnest, and you end up optimized for the exact jobs you are complaining about.
The second mistake is the fix that goes too far. A contractor hears “focus on the big jobs,” deletes every repair page, stops answering repair calls, and watches the pipeline for big jobs dry up because the front door closed. Do not do that either. Reduce attention. Do not amputate.
The third mistake is assuming the problem is traffic. It is not. You have the traffic. If you had traffic and no calls at all, you would want this breakdown of why website traffic produces no phone calls. Your problem is better than that. You have calls. They are just pointed at the wrong service.
What would we do this week?
We would stop writing anything new about the small service and write one page that makes the big service unmistakable.
Here is the order, in a single week:
- List every service on your homepage and Business Profile. Circle the one with the best margin. That is your bread and butter from now on.
- Rewrite the homepage headline and the first paragraph so the bread and butter is the first thing a visitor and Google read.
- Check your primary category. If it is a generic contractor category and a more specific one exists for your main service, switch it.
- Pull your last 20 reviews. If fewer than half mention the big service, start asking for reviews on big jobs only for the next 90 days.
- Replace the first six photos on your Business Profile with completed big jobs.
- Pick one bottom of funnel keyword for the big service, cost or process or near me, and plan a page that answers it better than anything ranking now.
That is it. Not a rebuild. A redirection.
If your market is one where a competitor is already locked in on the big-job keywords, you are in a harder fight and should read why a competitor is getting more calls than you before you spend. Hard is not impossible, but you should know going in.
When is this not worth doing?
Repositioning is not worth doing if the small jobs are actually your best business.
Some niches run on volume. Some pest control and some HVAC maintenance models make more money on a hundred small tickets than on ten big ones, and the small ticket is the start of a recurring relationship. If that is you, your Google traffic is correct and the thing to fix is your sales process and your upsell, not your keyword strategy.
It is also not worth doing if your crew cannot deliver the big job well yet. Ranking for roof replacement when you have never run a full replacement crew means bad reviews on the exact service you were trying to build. Earn the reviews, then chase the rankings.
And it is not worth doing if you are going to do it halfway. One new page about the big service, with a homepage and profile still screaming repairs, does nothing. Google reads the whole picture. If you are not going to shift the whole picture, keep what you have and work the lifetime value angle instead.
For everyone else, the question on the call was answered in one sentence, and it is the sentence to take with you. Talk about the services that you want more than you talk about the services that you don’t want.
This week: open your homepage, count how many sentences are about the job you want more of versus the job you want less of, and rewrite the headline and first paragraph until the profitable service wins that count.